Which Finds Are Worth a Second Look?
Thrifting can be one of the smartest ways to stretch your budget without giving up style, quality, or a little fun in the process. But which products are actually worth those hard-earned dollars, and which are worse than flushing your money away? We’re here to break down which deserve a closer look and which thrifted items only invite germs and headaches.
1. Denim Jackets
A thrift store is often the perfect place to find denim jackets! The truth is, they usually look better once they’ve already been broken in. Older versions also have sturdier fabric and more thoughtful construction than many fast-fashion options on the market now.
2. Leather Belts
Leather belts are one of the easiest accessories to thrift because quality leather develops more character over time. What’s even better is that you can usually spot a solid one by checking the stitching, the buckle, and whether the material feels dense in your hands.
3. Wool Coats
Thrift stores can be a goldmine for wool coats that would cost far more if bought new. Believe it or not, older coats usually have excellent tailoring and heavier fabric that feels genuinely warm. Just make sure you inspect for missing buttons or small wear; once you’re in the clear, the savings are substantial.
4. Silk Scarves
Silk scarves are often overlooked at thrift stores, which is exactly why you can find beautiful ones that haven’t been picked clean. They add polish to an outfit, work in every season, and can be worn in several ways without feeling overdone. And, since new silk can be pricey, picking it up secondhand is a smart move.
5. Cashmere Sweaters
Don’t assume you won’t find cashmere in a thrift store—you never know what’s waiting on shelves! As long as you check for pilling and tiny holes, you can walk away with something soft and luxurious for a fraction of the usual cost.
6. Blazers
A well-made blazer is absolutely worth thrifting, so don’t pass them by. You’ll often come across older blazers with better lining and stronger seams, which is a far cry from today’s cheaper versions. Even if the fit isn’t perfect, minor alterations can turn a secondhand find into one of the hardest-working pieces in your closet.
LOGAN WEAVER | @LGNWVR on Unsplash
7. Designer Handbags
You want to be careful with handbags; some of them are itching for another chance, and others arrived DOA. But with a good eye, you can score designer handbags at more approachable prices. Just pay attention to authenticity before committing.
8. Sunglasses
Vintage frames have a distinct look that feels stylish without trying too hard, and you’ll lock in a great pair at thrift stores. You’ll want to inspect the lenses carefully for scratches, but a great pair can give your collection a fresh update for very little money.
9. Unopened Nail Polish
Unopened nail polish is one of the safer options when it’s still sealed and in good condition. For any die-hard polish fans out there, you might score shades that were limited edition or discontinued, which makes the search a little more interesting.
10. Vintage Costume Jewelry
Costume jewelry often gets a bad rap as looking cheap—but that couldn’t be farther from the truth! Older earrings, brooches, and bracelets have more personality than many newer accessories, so when you want an outfit to feel more finished without overspending, costume jewelry rarely disappoints.
However, not all thrift store finds are diamonds in the rough. To keep your health and wallet safe, let’s dive into a few options you shouldn’t even think about.
1. Used Mascara
Mascara is a hotbed for bacteria to build up once it’s been opened. Even if the tube looks nearly full, there’s no reliable way to know how old it is or how it was stored. And since this product goes directly around your eyes, saving a few dollars isn’t worth it.
2. Lip Gloss
Secondhand lip products can seem tempting with cute packaging, but they’re not a safe purchase. Applicators go straight onto the mouth, which means germs can be transferred back into the tube after each use.
3. Opened Skin Care Products
You need to be especially careful with skin care. Once jars or tubes have been exposed, their formula may have changed, and contamination becomes a real concern. You might think you’re getting a premium item for less, but the uncertainty makes it a poor trade.
Enecta Cannabis extracts on Unsplash
4. Bathing Suits
Used bathing suits really aren’t worth the “steal.” Fabric in swimwear breaks down over time, even when the piece still looks presentable, and hygiene issues are always a concern. Not to mention, if elasticity has weakened or the lining has worn thin, you may not notice until you actually wear it.
5. Underwear
Underwear should stay firmly on your do-not-thrift list. There’s too much left in the air around prior use, washing methods, and general handling for it to be a sensible buy. Even when the price is tempting, this is one piece that doesn’t justify the gamble.
6. Heavily Worn Shoes
Shoes that already show significant wear can cause more trouble than they’re worth—and just because they look cute now, doesn’t mean they’ll remain that way at home. You can thrift footwear selectively, but once a pair looks worn down, it’s better to walk away.
7. Old Makeup Brushes
Makeup brushes are expensive, it’s true, but they’re worth every penny. Used beauty tools are not the place to get adventurous, especially when they’ve already had regular contact with skin and product buildup. Makeup sponges in particular are difficult to sanitize fully, and older brushes may hold residue in the bristles.
8. Stick-On Beauty Products
Adhesive fashion and beauty items lose their effectiveness quickly, so they’re hardly worth a few saved dollars. Even if they’re still a little sticky, you can’t count on them when you actually need them.
9. Expired Nail Treatments
Not every beauty product has the same shelf life, and specialty items become less reliable as they age. Nail strengtheners, lash serums, acne treatments, and similar formulas may not work as intended. Performance matters with stuff like this, so make sure you grab it new.
10. Damaged Hair Tools
Hair tools should be avoided if there’s any sign of damage, wear, or questionable wiring. The reality is that these items need to work safely, and thrifted versions don’t always give you enough information about their condition.
