Foundation Hits And Misses
Drugstore foundations can fool you fast. The packaging may shine, and the promises may sound perfect, but once it hits your skin, the truth shows. Some formulas disappoint right away, while others impress far more than expected. Here’s a breakdown of 10 foundations that fall flat—and 10 that absolutely deserve a spot in your routine.
L'OREAL INFALLIBLE FRESH WEAR FOUNDATION - IS IT REALLY WORTH THE HYPE?!! by Nikkia Joy
1. Revlon ColorStay Light Cover Foundation
You’d expect a lightweight formula to disappear into your skin, not slide around by lunchtime. While marketed as breathable and buildable, this one often dries too fast and clings to dry patches. The finish looks uneven in natural light, and blending takes extra effort.
NEW REVLON COLORSTAY LIGHT COVER FOUNDATION REVIEW + WEAR TEST by Sandi Jarquin
2. Wet N Wild Photo Focus Foundation
Plenty of pros once praised this for flash photography, yet everyday wear reveals its flaws. The chemical scent is distracting, and it tends to oxidize a full shade deeper. Under studio lighting, it performs. On real skin with pores and texture? It’s another story.
WET N WILD PHOTOFOCUS FOUNDATION | Wear test, First Impressions, Review by Amanda Rozze
3. Maybelline Dream Matte Mousse
At first touch, the whipped texture feels unique, almost playful. But that fades quickly. It sets too fast, exaggerates lines, and leaves no time to blend. On oily skin, it cakes up; on dry skin, it flakes off. It’s underwhelming.
4. E.L.F. Flawless Finish Foundation
This foundation seems like a steal. But the formula oxidizes, often darkening by a shade. What begins as a match can look off under sunlight. It also struggles to grip textured areas, making it unreliable for long wear or humid conditions.
e.l.f. Flawless Finish Foundation | Our Point Of View by WTI
5. Rimmel Lasting Finish 25HR Foundation
The formula claims to stay flawless all day; in reality, it breaks down within hours. It feels sticky after application and tends to oxidize. Though it offers full coverage, the thick texture can feel mask-like and uncomfortable on combination or oily skin types.
6. Covergirl Clean Liquid Foundation
Although the packaging looks gentle, the performance is another thing. It clings to dry patches and fades unevenly. The formula lacks flexibility; what you see after application is often the best it’ll look. For full workdays, you’ll need constant touch-ups and blotting sheets.
Is COVER GIRL CLEAN LIQUID FOUNDATION any good?? by Kelly M. Roach
7. Milani Conceal + Perfect 2-In-1
Heavy-duty coverage sounds like a plus. Still, it oxidizes and clings to texture if not applied fast with a dense brush. The 2-in-1 claim doesn’t live up to the hype; it creases under the eyes and breaks apart around the nose.
8. NYX Can’t Stop Won’t Stop Foundation
This one starts off promising: matte finish, decent shade range, full coverage. But wear it for more than six hours, and it tells a different story. It exaggerates dry areas and becomes patchy with sweat. Those with sensitive skin may also experience irritation.
NYX CAN'T STOP WON'T STOP FOUNDATION | Dry Skin Review & Wear Test by Geek Out of Water
9. Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Makeup
Rather than soothing breakouts, this Neutrogena foundation tends to spotlight them. Coverage goes on sheer, clings to blemishes, and wears off unevenly. Its staying power is also weak, and after just a few uses, the formula separates right inside the bottle.
Easy Everyday Long Lasting Makeup by Allie Glines
10. Almay Clear Complexion Makeup
Though marketed for sensitive skin, this foundation fails to deliver where it counts. The dated texture settles into fine lines by midday. It never truly dries down, and oxidation shifts the shade, turning color matching into an unpredictable struggle.
ALMAY CLEAR COMPLEXION FOUNDATION + CONCEALER Review / first impressions by Mariza Glam
Now it’s time for the bottles that earn their spot on your shelf. These picks don’t just look good on paper; they show up where it counts.
1. L’Oréal Infallible Fresh Wear Foundation
Long days call for formulas that don’t fade after lunch. This one delivers a breathable, buildable finish with surprisingly strong staying power. Plus, it blends easily with a brush, sponge, or fingers, making it reliable for both quick mornings and full glam sessions.
L'OREAL INFALLIBLE FRESH WEAR FOUNDATION - IS IT REALLY WORTH THE HYPE?!! by Nikkia Joy
2. Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless
For those wanting performance without the splurge, this foundation delivers. It balances oil, smooths texture, and avoids exaggerating pores. The matte finish stays fresh-looking, and the shade selection is wide enough to match most tones with ease and consistency.
MAYBELLINE FIT ME MATTE + PORELESS FOUNDATION REVIEW by Kristi Bergman
3. L’Oréal True Match Super-Blendable Foundation
The classic liquid foundation stands out for its smooth, buildable coverage and wide shade range. It blends easily with fingers or a sponge and adapts well to skin tone. The natural finish also works for all skin types.
4. Revlon ColorStay Makeup For Combo/Oily Skin
With a matte finish and long-wear formula, the foundation handles shine without going chalky. The coverage is medium to full, and it doesn’t slide off under pressure. Overall, it’s great for humid climates or full days when touch-ups just aren’t an option.
Revlon ColorStay for Combination/Oily Skin - No Primer Foundation by Stephanie Holiday
5. NYX Bare With Me Blur Tint Foundation
The blurred effect lives up to its name. It smooths over uneven texture and leaves a natural-satin finish. While the coverage is light to medium, it’s surprisingly buildable without caking. This one works especially well for those who want their skin to still look like skin.
6. Burt’s Bees Goodness Glows Liquid Foundation
This foundation brings medium coverage with a radiant finish, ideal for normal to dry skin. It blends smoothly and includes naturally derived ingredients without compromising wear time. Though lighter in texture, it builds well without caking and leaves skin looking fresh.
BURTS BEES GOODNESS GLOWS FOUNDATION | AMAZING DRUGSTORE FOUNDATION by Krystal Lynn (MakeupNme)
7. No7 Lift & Luminate Triple Action Foundation
Foundations that promise anti-aging effects usually disappoint, but this one smooths and brightens. It layers well over moisturizer and gives a light-to-medium finish that doesn’t crease. Bonus: it performs well under both powder and cream products.
Testing out the *NEW* No7. Serum Foundations...Which is better??? by Foundation Lady
8. L'Oréal Age Perfect Radiant Serum Foundation
Created with a focus on mature and dry skin, this serum-infused foundation provides hydration while evening out skin tone. The finish is soft, and the texture stays smooth all day. It resists creasing and clinging, even around fine lines. Ideal for lightweight coverage with a healthy glow.
Loreal Age Perfect Foundation by The Stuff I Use Channel
9. Physicians Formula The Healthy Foundation
A standout among drugstore bases, this foundation delivers hydration and comfort in one. It doesn’t settle into fine lines or exaggerate dry patches, even after a long day. The finish leans satin, offering just enough glow without tipping into oily territory.
NEW PHYSICIANS FORMULA THE HEALTHY FOUNDATION REVIEW by Emily Freybler
10. Almay Smart Shade Skintone Matching Makeup
This foundation’s pigment shifts to match your tone, easing shade-matching anxiety. It gives sheer, balanced coverage that applies easily and wears comfortably. With no added fragrance, it’s a clean, simple choice for those who prefer fuss-free application.
