Sorting The Lifesavers From The Letdowns
Nothing ruins a beach day like sunscreen that doesn’t do its job. Some formulas irritate, others underperform, and a few are just plain messy. Fortunately, there are reliable products out there that deliver what the label promises. But before spotlighting those, let’s unpack the brands you might want to leave on the shelf.
Neutrogena Hydroboost Sunscreen SPF 50 Review by Maryann Okonkwo
1. Hawaiian Tropic Sheer Touch Lotion SPF 30
The sunscreen gives a tropical scent and subtle shimmer, but that’s where the perks end. Lab tests showed it blocked only 71.27% of UVA rays after two hours, falling short of long-term protection. With a modest UVA/UVB balance and lack of water resistance, it’s poorly suited for extended outdoor use or intense sun exposure.
Hawaiian Tropic Sheer Touch SPF 30 Sunscreen by The Internet Sorcerer
2. Neutrogena Wet Skin Kids Sunscreen Spray SPF 70+
Formulated for use on damp skin, this spray offers convenience for reapplication at pools and beaches. However, EWG rates its UVA/UVB balance as moderate, suggesting potential limitations in UVA protection. The application of spray sunscreen may also result in uneven coverage if not applied carefully.
Neutrogena Wet Skin Sunblock - Quick Demo by Lindsey
3. CVS Health Clear Zinc SPF 50
Although zinc oxide checks the protection box, the texture makes it nearly unusable. Thick and hard to spread evenly, users often report streaking and missed spots. Consumer Reports even ranked it poorly in 2021, citing inconsistent UVA protection that makes it unsuitable when full-body coverage is non-negotiable.
Top 5 Sunscreens | My Favorite Sunscreens by Zac Malone
4. Coppertone Sport Sunscreen Lotion SPF 50
Designed for sweat and water resistance, this lotion does neither particularly well. EWG data lists concerning ingredients and fragrance allergens. In fact, numerous consumer complaints reference rashes and eye irritation. And, it's no longer the go-to for athletes prioritizing both skin safety and performance.
Coppertone SPF 50 Sport Sunscreen for Face - 2.5 oz tube by SammyLu Reviews
5. Alba Botanica Hawaiian Sunscreen SPF 45
The label claims to be “reef-friendly” and plant-based, but the ingredients tell a different story. Two controversial chemical filters are present, which contradict the natural branding. It also left a sticky residue in multiple independent user tests. The composition and texture place it far behind better-performing mineral-based alternatives.
Alba Botanica Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 50, Island Vibe, 3 Oz by Andi & Jeff Reviews
6. Sun Bum Original SPF 50 Spray
Spray sunscreens often miss the mark, and this popular one is no exception. A 2021 EWG review flagged it for including chemical filters linked to skin irritation. Uneven application can further lead to patchy protection, undermining its tropical-cool branding with preventable sun damage.
7. Walgreens Dry Touch Sunscreen SPF 100
High-SPF products can lure buyers into a false sense of long-lasting safety. This store-brand lotion, for instance, contains several ingredients that are considered controversial. Its greasy finish also contradicts the "dry touch" promise, and its ingredient list hasn’t kept pace with more effective options now widely available.
SOOO DONE with These: Sunscreen for Darker Skin + MORE Skincare by The Style and Beauty Doctor
8. Equate Sport Sunscreen Spray SPF 50
Equate's spray formula has been cited by Consumer Reports for inadequate UVA defense. Users report uneven spray patterns and excessive alcohol content that can dry out the skin. Intended for active use, it underdelivers in terms of both durability and comfort during extended outdoor activities.
Equate Sport Spray Sunscreen by The Everyday Momma Product Reviews
9. Babyganics Sunscreen Lotion SPF 50+
Marketed as gentle and mineral-based, it uses zinc oxide and titanium dioxide as active ingredients. While free from chemical UV filters, the EWG’s 2025 database notes moderate concerns regarding its UVA protection strength. Inconsistent water resistance and thick texture further limit its reliability for full-body outdoor use.
Shopping The Best Sunscreens At Target 2024 by Dr Dray
10. Panama Jack Sunscreen Lotion SPF 15
An SPF 15 rating falls below dermatological recommendations for daily wear, let alone extended outdoor exposure. Although marketed with a tropical flair, it lacks essential water resistance and contains multiple synthetic fragrances. For beachgoers or even light sun exposure, this lotion simply doesn't provide science-backed protection.
FACT CHECK: Is sunscreen tax exempt? by KRIS 6 News
Not every bottle on the shelf is a letdown. Some formulas actually deliver what they promise, and your skin can tell the difference. Let’s get into the good stuff.
1. Neutrogena Hydro Boost SPF 50 Body Gel
Unlike traditional creams, this gel formula provides a fast-absorbing texture ideal for daily wear. It uses chemical filters but includes hyaluronic acid, which helps hydrate dry skin. Lightweight and non-greasy, it’s a favorite among dermatologists for broad-spectrum protection without the heaviness many body sunscreens carry.
Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel Lotion SPF 50 Wear Test by CHRISTINA MARIE
2. La Roche-Posay Anthelios Melt-In Milk SPF 60
Sun care meets comfort in the silky, fragrance-free formula that glides across skin and vanishes without a trace. Backed by professionals and consumers alike, La Roche-Posay offers high SPF coverage with a gentle touch. Water resistance further ensures ongoing defense through sweat, waves, and heat.
3. Blue Lizard Sensitive Mineral SPF 50+
Originally developed in Australia, this mineral sunscreen protects sensitive skin without irritation. It’s fragrance-free and water-resistant for 80 minutes. The color-changing bottle cap adds a clever touch, as it turns blue in response to harmful UV light, reminding users when protection is needed most.
4. Banana Boat Light As Air SPF 50+ Lotion
The formula lives up to its name with a breathable, weightless feel. It offers broad-spectrum protection and dries quickly. Unlike older Banana Boat versions, this sunscreen is free from oxybenzone and parabens, while also earning high marks for texture, wearability, and reapplication comfort.
5. Neutrogena Sheer Zinc SPF 50+
Zinc oxide leads the defense in a sunscreen praised for comfort and gentleness. Many prefer the sheer finish that disappears on contact. With no added fragrances or parabens, the product appeals to those with reactive skin seeking strong sun protection without harsh chemical additives.
Neutrogena Sheer Zinc Sunscreen SPF 50 Review by razorantum
6. Coppertone Pure & Simple Baby SPF 50
Gentle mineral protection doesn’t require sacrificing effectiveness. The zinc oxide formula resists water for up to 80 minutes and also avoids the additives that commonly cause skin irritation. Designed for infants yet embraced by adults, it delivers dependable coverage with a calm, simple ingredient list.
COPPERTONE SUNSCREEN LOTION/PURE & SIMPLY BABY WITH 100% MINERAL by THE OTT’S CHANNEL
7. Aveeno Protect + Hydrate SPF 60
Oat extract gives Aveeno sunscreen a skin-calming edge, making it suitable for dry or easily irritated skin. Its oil-free and non-comedogenic formula offers strong SPF 60 protection while moisturizing the skin. In fact, the sunscreen is often recommended for daily use in warmer climates.
Aveeno Protect + Hydrate Face Sunscreen | Our Point Of View by WTI
8. Beautycounter Countersun Mineral SPF 30
This mineral lotion uses non-nano zinc oxide, avoiding two ingredients banned in reef-sensitive areas (oxybenzone and octinoxate). Therefore, those sensitive to harsh ingredients appreciate the absence of parabens and artificial scents. Although SPF 30 is moderate, it remains a solid choice for non-intensive sun exposure.
9. Thinksport Safe Sunscreen SPF 50+
The first sunscreen to pass Whole Foods' strict ingredient screening, Thinksport’s formula uses non-nano zinc oxide and avoids biologically harmful chemicals. It offers water resistance for 80 minutes and a surprisingly non-greasy finish, so it is popular among athletes and outdoor workers.
Our Point of View on thinksport Kid's Safe Sunscreen From Amazon by WTI
10. Babo Botanicals Clear Zinc SPF 30
Certified by both the EWG and NSF Organic, Babo Botanicals offers a gentle mineral sunscreen with 19.2% zinc oxide. The formula includes organic calendula and shea butter for added skin nourishment. While SPF 30 is modest, eco-conscious users may appreciate the biodegradable packaging and ingredients.
Babo Botanicals Clear Zinc Sunscreen Application for face and neck & review by Jessica Fischer
