×

The 20 Most Overrated Skincare Products of All Time


The 20 Most Overrated Skincare Products of All Time


Beauty Industry Bluff

Skincare can feel like a maze built out of marketing. One friend swears by her crystal roller, another can’t live without her luxury cream. Yet somehow, your skin still looks the same no matter what you do. Turns out, a lot of these so-called essentials are just good stories in pretty bottles with no effectiveness. So, let’s peel back the labels and see which products aren’t worth the fuss.

Darina BelonogovaDarina Belonogova on Pexels

1. Luxury Face Creams

Many luxury face creams contain the same basic moisturizing ingredients as drugstore alternatives. Often, these creams are sold in jars designed to look like jewelry boxes to enhance their perceived value. However, they lack sufficient concentrations of proven actives.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T184055.526.jpgShe's OBSESSED! La Mer Moisturizing Cream (FULL REVIEW) by Shop with Nez

2. Jade Rollers And Gua Sha Tools

Don't be fooled by the allure of jade rollers and gua sha tools. Although they've been part of Chinese beauty routines for ages, their claims of lymphatic drainage and facial sculpting are unproven. The cooling effect is merely temporary.

KATRIN  BOLOVTSOVAKATRIN BOLOVTSOVA on Pexels

3. Collagen-Infused Topical Products

A protein originally found in the skin, collagen, is often marketed as a key skincare ingredient. However, collagen molecules in topical products are too big to penetrate the skin and stimulate collagen production. The base of these products is what provides the most benefits.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T183554.344.jpgI Tried the Advanced Clinicals Collagen Cream | A Review - Laura Garza by Laura Garza

Advertisement

4. Sheet Masks With Single-Use Premium Pricing

Originating in South Korea, sheet masks quickly became a global trend. However, their effects rarely extend beyond a few hours, and they're often sold at a premium price. Adding to their inflated reputation, some are even made from bio-cellulose.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T183113.104.jpgBest VIRAL K-BEAUTY MASKS! | We tested them for 30 days, and... by Beauty Within

5. Oxygen Facials 

The science behind these treatments is dubious at best. After all, there is no proof that topical oxygen can penetrate or benefit skin cells. Our skin receives oxygen from blood circulation, not from the surface. Furthermore, oxygen facial devices deliver minimal active ingredients. 

RM%20-%202025-11-04T102203.691.jpgWhat Is Intraceuticals Oxygen Facial? (Instant Glow) by London Premier Laser & Skin Clinic

6. Pore Strips And Nose Strips

Although they may temporarily remove superficial debris, pore strips fail to address the root causes of blackheads. The visible "gunk" on strips is mostly sebaceous filaments, not true blackheads. Moreover, they can cause irritation, making them a poor long-term solution.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T111910.533-1.jpgFULL FACE OF BIORE NOSE STRIPS!! | charlene marilyn by charlene marilyn

7. Gold-Infused Skincare Products

Gold-infused skincare products tend to dazzle consumers with their 24K gold flakes, a purely cosmetic addition. Despite the historical myths and marketing claims, there's no credible evidence that gold offers unique skin benefits or that Cleopatra ever used gold masks. 

RM%20-%202025-11-04T103656.926.jpgDoes GOLD Skincare work? First time trying 24k gold on my face by Kev's World

8. Detox Face Masks With Activated Charcoal

While activated charcoal excels in water filters and poison treatments, its skincare prowess is questionable. In detox face masks, it merely absorbs surface oil and dirt, a far cry from the promised detoxification. Furthermore, these masks may stain your towels and clothing.

RM%20-%202025-11-04T104324.245.jpgFleur & Bee | Prince Charcoal - Detox Face Mask by Fleur & Bee

9. Anti-Aging Eye Creams

The skincare industry often overvalues anti-aging eye creams. With nearly identical ingredients to regular face moisturizers, eye creams are sold at a premium. The elevated price is attributed to smaller packaging and strategic marketing, not unique benefits. 

RM%20-%202025-11-04T104055.837.jpg[UNPAID] Review: L'Oreal Paris Revitalift Eye Cream by Scarlette Reviews

Advertisement

10. LED Light Therapy Masks

At-home LED masks, with their sci-fi prop-like appearance, promise a dermatology clinic experience. Turns out they are far less potent than professional devices. Additionally, there's scant evidence to substantiate their benefits for acne or wrinkles.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T105613.808.jpgDo LED Masks Really Work? Red Light Therapy at Home (Transformation video) by Smitha Deepak

11. Snail Mucin Products With Unproven Claims

Once hailed as a miracle ingredient, snail mucin became a K-beauty sensation, promising everything from deep hydration to scar healing. The idea originated from snail farmers in Chile who noticed their hands healed quickly after handling snails.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T105218.544.jpgSnail Mucin in skincare (1 week BEFORE & AFTER), COSRX Advanced Snail 96 mucin power essence Review by Shelley Nayak

12. Dermaplaning Tools For At-Home Use

Dermaplaning tools for at-home use are often marketed as "painless," but don't be fooled. These tools can increase the risk of cuts, irritation, and infection due to their lack of precision and safety compared to professional treatments. 

RM%20-%202025-11-03T104723.425.jpgHow to Dermaplane with Sonicsmooth by Michael Todd Beauty

13. Vitamin C Serums Above 20% Concentration

Given that the skin can only absorb a certain amount of vitamin C, higher concentrations are unnecessary. Vitamin C serums with more than 20% concentration are not more effective; in fact, they can irritate the skin. Additionally, vitamin C oxidizes rapidly.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T103710.339.jpgNIOD ETHYLATED L-ASCORBIC ACID 30% NETWORK by Sincerely Miss Ash

14. Microcurrent Facial Devices

Microcurrent facial devices, originally used in physical therapy, have been repurposed with claims of toning facial muscles. However, the results are often subtle and temporary. Users have also reported experiencing a metallic taste during use, a result of the electrical currents.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T103326.474.jpgI tried microcurrent for 3 years ( NuFace + EMS — not sponsored ) by The Science of Self-Care

15. Enzyme Peels Marketed As "Natural Alternatives"

Beware of enzyme peels' marketing gimmicks. Their 'gentle' exfoliation is significantly milder compared to acids. Laced with fruit extracts like papaya or pineapple, they're sold as 'natural' products. By the way, their pleasant scent doesn't guarantee better results. 

RM%20-%202025-11-03T102255.766.jpgELEMIS PAPAYA ENZYME PEEL FIRST IMPRESSIONS | GLOWY AUTUMN EVENING SKINCARE ROUTINE | byalicexo by byalicexo

Advertisement

16. Under-Eye Patches

The world of skincare has seen its fair share of fads, and under-eye patches are no exception. Despite their fun shapes and glitter for social media clout, they offer little beyond a temporary cooling sensation. The reduction in puffiness is due to the cold temperature.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T102155.345.jpg24K Gold Under Eye Masks Review – 30 Pairs Anti-Aging Patches for Puffy Eyes & Dark Circles! by Only One Judy

17. Hyaluronic Acid Products Without Proper Molecular Weight

Hyaluronic acid, a very famous skincare superstar, can hold a staggering 1,000 times its weight in water. However, effectiveness is compromised when products use high molecular weight hyaluronic acid that merely lingers on the skin's surface. 

RM%20-%202025-11-03T094826.947.jpgDr. Sugai Reviews: Vichy Mineral 89 Serum by Dr. Daniel Sugai

18. Face Mists And Thermal Water Sprays

You should be aware that mists and thermal sprays primarily comprise water and offer only short-lived hydration. Their effects dissipate quickly as the water evaporates from the skin. In fact, continuous misting can exacerbate skin dryness due to evaporation. 

RM%20-%202025-11-03T094429.172.jpgI tried 6 ICONIC French Pharmacy Toners & Thermal mists - worth it for sensitive skin ? ( PART 6 ) by Shelley Nayak

19. Overnight Lip Masks With Standard Balm Ingredients

Many overnight lip masks are flavored to mimic desserts, a marketing strategy designed to entice consumers. However, they often contain the same basic emollients and occlusives as standard lip balms, offering no unique benefits. The "mask" label, too, is more marketing than substance.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T093418.478.jpgBurts Bees Conditioning Lip Scrub & Overnight Intensive Lip Treatment Review by itsjustmejamie

20. Skin Tightening Creams With Instant Results Claims

Instant results from skin tightening creams? Think again. These products use film-forming agents to create a fleeting tightening sensation, often misinterpreted as actual firming. Disturbingly, no scientific proof confirms their claims of sustained tightening or lifting benefits.

RM%20-%202025-11-03T093304.080.jpgI TRIED THE VIRAL "MIRACLE" NECK CREAM....4 WEEK RESULTS! by Jen Phelps