Hits And Misses Among Drugstore Cleansers
Drugstore cleansers have long carried a strange duality. While some feel like comforting staples, others strip away the very skin they promise to protect. Over the decades, marketing slogans, trendy ingredients, and nostalgic packaging have shaped which bottles landed in bathroom cabinets. But gentle doesn’t always mean safe, and familiar doesn’t always mean effective. This list explores which cleansers deserve your trust, and which ones you’re better off leaving on the shelf, starting with the latter.
St. Ives Face Scrub | Our Point Of View by WTI
1. St. Ives Apricot Scrub
Once hailed as America’s best-selling facial scrub, St. Ives Apricot Scrub earned both loyalty and lawsuits. Dermatologists cautioned that its crushed walnut shells caused micro-tears in delicate skin. Headlines compared it to “sandpaper on your face,” yet nostalgia keeps it alive.
Calyxta Reviews: St. Ives Apricot Oil Scrub by Calyxta
2. Clean & Clear Morning Burst
Bright colors and zingy fragrance contributed to making Clean & Clear Morning Burst a teenage bathroom staple. But behind the neon beads and foamy fun hides sodium laureth sulfate and heavy fragrance, which are guilty of stripping skin.
Clean & Clear Morning Burst Facial Cleanser - Quick Review by RCD Reviews
3. Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash
The sleek orange bottle once felt futuristic, delivering a squeaky-clean finish. Packed with 2% salicylic acid, it often left skin red, flaky, and oilier than before. Despite cult status in the 2000s, modern experts dismiss this harsh formula as damaging.
HONEST NEUTROGENA OIL FREE ACNE WASH REVIEW! You won't believe what happened!!! by Nicole Lisa
4. Biore Charcoal Cleanser
Foaming into a dramatic black lather, Biore’s Charcoal Cleanser looked like a mini spa moment at the sink. Menthol gave it a tingling “party” sensation, but not everyone’s skin celebrated. With no proof that charcoal clears pores, it mostly fueled social media trends.
BIORE CHARCOAL CLEANSER! (DAUGHTER & MOM REVIEW) by Aiden Marshall
5. Noxzema Classic Clean
Noxzema Classic Clean promised the unforgettable “Noxzema sensation!” A cooling burn from menthol and camphor made it feel effective, though science says otherwise. Born in 1914, this retro cleanser is more nostalgic than practical.
Noxzema Classic Clean Original Deep Cleansing Cream face REVIEW by RealBeautiful Beauty
6. Biore Pore Unclogging Scrub
Hoping for smooth, poreless skin, many were drawn to Biore’s Pore Unclogging Scrub, yet its rough beads and salicylic acid frequently backfired. Redness, flaking, and over-exfoliation were common results. Despite its gritty texture, people kept buying for the instant “polished” feeling.
7. Aveeno Positively Radiant Cleanser
Aveeno’s Positively Radiant Cleanser relied on sulfates and fragrance that often stripped skin and triggered irritation. Its “soy complex” promised radiance but offered little proof in a wash-off product. Early selfie-glow ads boosted its fame; however, many users felt dryness rather than the radiance advertised.
8. Clearasil Daily Face Wash
Few acne products became as iconic as Clearasil Daily Face Wash. Infused with benzoyl peroxide, it attacked breakouts aggressively but often left skin red, flaky, and stripped. Its bleaching effect on towels became legendary.
Clearasil Ultra Daily Face Wash Rapid Action 12hours clearer skin REVIEW by RealBeautiful Beauty
9. L’Oréal Paris Go 360 Clean
L’Oréal’s Go 360 Clean promised innovation with its attached “scrublet” brush. But the tool often over-exfoliated and collected bacteria, while the foaming cleanser itself stripped skin of natural oils. Despite clever packaging, poor reviews led to discontinuation in some markets.
L'Oreal Go 360 Clean review by lovefashion5
10. Garnier SkinActive Micellar Foaming Cleanser
Borrowing the buzzword “micellar,” Garnier’s foaming cleanser confused consumers from the start. Unlike true micellar water, it foamed, required rinsing, and left residue when skipped. Its pink packaging became shorthand for marketing missteps, as users realized the formula contradicted micellar’s gentle reputation.
NEW: Garnier Micellar Foaming Cleanser by Space Case
Now that you know what to avoid, let’s show you those that deserve your money.
1. CeraVe Hydrating Facial Cleanser
CeraVe Hydrating Facial Cleanser blends three ceramides with hyaluronic acid, helping skin stay soft instead of tight. Dermatologists consistently recommend it for dryness and sensitivity, while fans sent it viral as “hydration in a bottle.” Cradle-to-Cradle certification even underscores its eco-friendly design.
CeraVe Hydrating Cream To Foam Cleanser & Hydrating Facial Cleanser Review by itsjustmejamie
2. La Roche-Posay Toleriane Hydrating Gentle Cleanser
Infused with niacinamide and soothing prebiotic thermal water, La Roche-Posay’s Toleriane Cleanser caters to the most delicate skin. Dermatologists praise it for cleansing without barrier damage, and Allergy UK approves it for sensitive users. Many insist it’s the only product their reactive skin tolerates.
LA ROCHE POSAY VS CERAVE SHOWDOWN // it's like choosing your favorite kid | Rudi Berry by Rudi Berry
3. E.l.f. Pure Skin Cleanser
Fans crowned E.l.f.’s Pure Skin Cleanser a “$9 dupe” after praising its softening, non-drying results. It contains oat milk, niacinamide, ceramides, and hyaluronic acid, and delivers high-end ingredients without the cost. Vegan, cruelty-free, and dermatologist-developed, it gained PETA and Fair Trade recognition.
IS E.L.F PURE SKIN THE NEW HOLY GRAIL? // DERMATOLOGIST @DrDrayzday by Dr Dray
4. Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser
Free from fragrance, parabens, dyes, and sulfates, Vanicream has become a go-to for eczema and hypersensitive skin. Dermatologists and allergists often recommend it, while parents slip it into baby kits for gentle use. Beloved by those with chronic conditions, it’s famed for simplicity.
How to use Vanicream Gentle Facial Cleanser by Melissa Van Dijk
5. RoC Dermatologic Daily Cleansing Gel
RoC’s Dermatologic Daily Cleansing Gel merges French heritage with drugstore accessibility. Soap-free and non-comedogenic, it hydrates with glycerin and respects the skin’s barrier. Known for its anti-aging legacy, RoC aligns this cleanser with its retinol-focused line.
BEST DRUGSTORE FACE WASH/ ROC CLEANSING PADS & CERAVE by Bibi GOLD - Scrubs & Heels
6. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Cleansing Gel
Bright, water-blue gel sets the stage for Neutrogena Hydro Boost. Infused with hyaluronic acid, it clears impurities while adding weightless hydration. Fans praise its light and water-like texture, describing it as refreshing and gentle. Unlike many drugstore cleansers, it leaves skin plump, never tight.
How to use the Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel Cleanser | Full Demonstration by Melissa Van Dijk
7. Simple Kind To Skin Moisturizing Facial Wash
Long before “minimalism” became a hashtag, Simple’s Kind to Skin Wash was already rewriting routines. Soap-free and enriched with pro-vitamin B5, it avoids perfumes and harsh chemicals. A UK cult hit that expanded globally, it’s gentle enough for morning, post-workout, and bedtime.
8. Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat Cleanser
Just imagine the soothing comfort of an oat bath, bottled into a cleanser. That’s Aveeno Calm + Restore, blending colloidal oatmeal with a gentle milky gel. With no added scent or essential oils, it’s fragrance-free and restores calm to redness-prone skin.
Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat Cleanser Review! by 8thDayBeauty
9. Yes To Cucumbers Gentle Milk Cleanser
Yes To Cucumbers relies on aloe and cucumber extract in a creamy, non-foaming base designed for sensitive skin. Its refreshing scent turns cleansing into a spa-like pause. Praised for real gentleness, customers repurpose bottles as travel-size makeup removers.
Product of the Week: Yes to Cucumbers! by Beautynewbie
10. Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser (Updated Formula)
Free of parabens and sulfates, Cetaphil’s updated Gentle Cleanser includes vitamin B3 and B5 to bolster barrier health. Dermatologist-endorsed worldwide, it’s fragrance-free and suitable for sensitive skin. Many long-time users insist it feels better than the nostalgic original.
